That’s gas – eh no it’s electricity!
Posted by Maman Poulet on 19 Feb 2009 at 02:57 am | Tagged as: Blogging, Consumer blogging
Bord Gáis Energy launched yesterday with their entry into the residential electricity market known as the Big Switch. There was lots of coverage on mainstream media outlets including quizzing of the electricity regulator (a man you never hear on the radio except for obligatory appearance when price rises are announced!) on News at One with Sean O’Rourke.
A new player in the residential electricity market – Bord Gais Energy will provide/resell energy to people at reduced rates compared to the ESB – at least 10% off in year one, 5% in year two, and 5% in year three. If the customer pays by direct debit there will be a further discount and another discount if one is also a gas customer. (550,000 of them!)
If the ESB put their prices down then the Bord Gáis Energy prices will go down also. 15,000 farmers have already made the big switch to electricity from Bord Gáis last year and all seems to be going well. If thats not the case I’m sure someone will make a comment
There has been competition in the provision of electricity to business customers and there are other companies entering the residential sector. But for Bord Gáis Energy this is a big move – two semi states competing against each other is also something new. The big player having their hand tied behind their back in terms of price setting is a factor to be considered – according to the regulator it’s so others can compete. But that won’t be the situation for ever.
So how come I know all about this??
The night before the launch I attended an off the record preview of the campaign launch for blogging types and got to see the poster ads, tv ads, and hear the radio spots. The marketing team from Bord Gais were there – they wanted to talk to bloggers, and more importantly listen to bloggers about how not only to market online but to listen and learn from online interactions. There was no bullshit and lots and lots of questions and loads of answers.
We learnt that people will be encouraged to sign up either online or by phoning the company to make the switch. There will also be door-to-door switch team which will be tightly regulated and salary based rather than commission – so I hope no Eircom Phonewatch scare stories (i remember the day a friend rang me about to sign up after the lovely people had got into the kitchen and filled her full of scare stories so much she was scared shitless – she rang me for some bank stuff and I managed to shout stop and think and how much was it really going to cost! Phonewatch were sent on their way by me and I was not even in the house at the time!)
In relation to online strategies and the future engagement by Bord Gáis Energy my advice to the company would be
1. Blog as a company about the new product – get stories of people who have switched and get them to write about the process. (and don’t pay them a gratuity like AIB do for the radio/tv ad – and disclose it!! In fact disclose everything – people appreciate not being bullshitted to!)
2. Get someone to keep an eye on issues which pop up online – on blogs, boards.ie or rollercoaster or the various mommy boards – those who talk about the bills, who don’t understand the process or who are getting the run around from a service provider. Prediction :- Online community managers will be a regular feature of customer service staffing in many of Ireland’s major companies in the next 2-3 years and I don’t mean people just managing their own company’s forum – but monitoring and engaging with what’s happening outside.
3. Go viral on some ads! On Bord Gais Energy’s youtube account they put up their 50/50 cashback ad from 15-20 years ago – brilliant idea and I was jigging along to it in my sofa. I can see lots of other companies bringing us back their old ads as well as new stuff online to build brand allegiance and memory especially when going in a new direction. And don’t get too upset when someone does a pisstake of the Big Switch television or radio ads or photoshops Lucy Kennedy – tell the cynical business mandarins on the top floor that it’s brand building!
From what I heard on the night I do think there are a number of consumer issues which need to be dealt with and I’ve mentioned some of them before.
- A binding – and not voluntary – code of conduct of behaviour of all players in the market. Many of the bloggers present the other night could tell a story or twenty about phone deregulation, selling of services and pressure from the market leader trying to get people back to their service. Comreg is not known as Eircom’s poodle for no reason!
- So if your Aunty Mary decides to make the big switch she is guaranteed that she can do so without interference from the company she is leaving. The company she is signing up to has to be clear and transparent in their dealings also. A do not call registry is also needed – or at least a beefing up of the existing one. Fines should be levied where it can be proved people were signed over to new agencies without their consent and all barriers to changing over that have been identified in the deregulation of the telecom industry should be prevented from occurring in the electricity market straight off.
- We need a consumer led energy watchdog – the regulator should regulate the industry but we need to have a group funded independently which handles customer complaints and makes representations on behalf of customers generally to the regulator and other bodies. (For those who think we have them already – The Consumer Association of Ireland is a private body with no mandate from anyone, the National Consumer Agency is a fairly toothless government watchdog with lackeys and mates on the board on little earners.)
In case you are interested I did not get paid to write the above or attend the session - I got a glass of still mineral water and a cushioned chair to sit on during the presentation and thats it.
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](http://img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png?x-id=078584b1-c075-48f6-8ead-3a4d6bfe32c6)
why you?, why damien mulley, big fans of the consumer electricity market?, been blogging on it for years?
seems you got paid in flattery
Sw – you going to come out behind your fake email address? Ah go on – amuse us! I replied to a post on this and was not specifically asked to attend – I’ve blog frequently about consumer blogging issues – even have a category of my blog dedicated to it – have a read! – and about how companies interact with consumers on and offline.
I’ve not recommended one provider over another in the post above have I? I’ve talked about a new product, how it’s been rolled out, how a company could relate to consumers online and about the issues of deregulation of electricity.
By the by – I spent 2 hours of my own time at the meeting (and paid for my own taxis there and back!)
did the ask any blogger who knew anything about the electricity market?
did anyone ask about privatisation? which have led to purposefully brown outs with enron etc?
would you have posted about this if not invited?
what other companies are involved?
any one say anything about energy security, corrib?
Lots of questions on energy security, responsiblity for maintaining services, corrib, Bord Gais’s own plans for energy production, and environmental issues in energy production. It’s not my specialization so I didn’t blog it. There were bloggers there who know a lot about the energy market and energy production.
I would post about this issue if not invited since it’s being debated online by others – particularly in the need to protect consumers in making a switch and in price setting issues. I read in today’s Irish Times that Airtricity are coming back into the residential property market and if they would like to tell me about it all they now know how to get in touch with me (hit the contact button up on top right hand side). Same for ESB!
Now I’ve learnt more about energy regulation and pricing in particular I will continue to blog in the area. There was no PR company involved in this by the way. It was direct dialogue.
I am actually working on a piece on the ESB and the hush hush/non response over price irregularities experienced by customers in recent weeks – far beyond the 20% price increase. (I discussed some of the background on the issue it with some bloggers in attendance last night)
i know i’d be more impressed if bord gais engaged with the bloggersphere rather then simply talked to some bloggers( who were invited by their mate who made their website)
No making of website involved in anyone there as far as I know – they actually did engage with bloggersphere and did not specifically invite a chosen few – read the post which invited people along! And you can see Bord Gáis engaging with people online on twitter – http://twitter.com/TheBigSwitchIRL You will note one of the points I’ve made in the post is that I think Bord Gáis Energy should also blog. Not to engage with bloggers – with consumers! Bloggers are not gods!
My interest is in making it easier for consumers to access rights and stop being treated so shoddily and thereby making companies better communicators. I don’t get paid to work in the area and have no interest in moving in to the sector.
I agree on BG having someone keep an eye on what the word is on the Tubes. But they have to avoid leaving comments along the lines of ‘we at Bord Gáis are moving forward with our customer care strategy’ etc etc blah blah. The only desirable engagement is for someone to say ‘thanks for flagging that: I’ll see what we can do for you’ and for them to do it. As far as I can see, lots of corporate 2.0 marketing reveals that few companies seem to know why the difference is important.
On another subject, I was poking around yesterday but couldn’t 100% verify whether the leccy and the gas come in on one bill. And whether falling behind on payments on one, as a matter of policy, would lead to you being cut off on both. That would be a serious issue when it comes to spreading the benefits of the market to people who could most do with the cut in bills: what risks do they run when times are bad?
The bills are going to be seperate Ciarán – one of the bloggers present the other night asked that question. I’m not sure if there is a published code in terms of cutting of service for non payment of utility bills in Ireland – but am aware from my day job that MABS work with utility companies on these issues on behalf of clients.
[...] Suzy Byrne was there and blogged about the consumer side of the equation (as well as the street teams planned). Peter D, AdIreland and Damien Mulley all blogged about this new-found openness. [...]
Thanks MP. I recall that the ESB had a problem with cutting electricity off when people fell behind on HP debts for cookers etc. I think it might all have ended up in court many years ago but couldn’t remember.
Anyway, thanks for answering the question.
In part response to sw above, there was no secret agenda from bloggers as to the organising of the Bord Gais meeting. We didn’t even know who we’d be meeting beyond that they were a large Irish company with an announcement to make. It was recorded openly several times on Damien Mulley’s site. An invite like ‘If you’re a blogger please come along’ is not exactly asking for a masonic handshake.
Legitimate questions about Corrib etc aside, there’s a bitter tone to your queries. None of us, as far as I’m aware, stand to gain anything personally as bloggers via BG’s early announcement to us. It wasn’t a closed shop. Bord Gais was open and transparent about what they were doing. The only secretive aspect of any of this is your identity.