Maman Poulet | Clucking away crookedly through media, politics and life

Diplomatic hypocrisy?

January 1st, 2012 · 7 Comments · Equality, Irish Politics

Today is the World Day of Peace, a Catholic celebration.  Each year it is traditional for the Taoiseach to issue a statement on the day in response to the annual statement issued by the Pope.  Frostiness or not in the relations between Ireland and the Vatican, Enda Kenny issued a statement this morning and indeed attended mass in Haddington Road with other politicians to mark the occasion.

In his statement the Taoiseach announced that Ireland would be seeking election to the UN Human Rights Council.

Both within our own country, and in the wider world, Ireland is at the fore of those promoting peace, justice, security and development. This is a commitment and an engagement that we take with the utmost seriousness that this why, this year, for the first time, Ireland is seeking election to the United Nations Human Rights Council. If elected, Ireland would support clear and strong action by the Council in addressing human rights violations and in promoting universal respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms.

The Human Rights Council

is an inter-governmental body within the UN system made up of 47 States responsible for strengthening the promotion and protection of human rights around the globe.  The Council was created by the UN General Assembly on 15 March 2006 with the main purpose of addressing situations of human rights violations and make recommendations on them.

I assume before Ireland applies for election that

  • the Mental Capacity Bill will be debated and enacted?
  • The UN Convention on the Rights of People with Disabilities will be ratified by the government.
  • Residential facilities for people with disabilities will be monitored and inspected.
  • All prisoners will have in cell sanitation.
  • Prisoners with mental health problems will be provided with appropriate treatment and facilities.
  • The Government will truly strengthen and maintain the independence of the Equality and Human Rights infrastructure in the state.
  • The Magdelene women will be cared for and apologised to.
  • Travellers will be recognised as an ethnic minority.

Insert other areas where Ireland’s human rights record is poor and we fail to meet international conventions

Put simply we should attend to everything else which should be required of us  before applying to join such an elite.  The Office of the UN High Commissioner for Human Rights assessed our record with regard to treaties and conventions last year and it and the Universal Periodic Review (draft report) show the concerns of the United Nations in many areas of human rights and legal protections.

Indeed the human rights record of many of the other members of the Human Rights Council is also far from perfect.  But is it too much to hope that we could lead by example and prioritise attending to our human rights obligations?  This could then be seen as ‘clear and strong’ action by the Government in ‘addressing human rights violations and in promoting universal respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms.’

See what I did there?  Austerity can not be an excuse for such diplomatic hypocrisy either.

Happy New Year.

Share

Tags:

7 Comments so far

  • Adam

    I would add Kenny and FG’s failure to support extending marriage and adoption rights to same-sex couples to your list. The Section 37 equality opt out also needs to be repealed and the discrimatory ban on gay and bisexual men donating blood lifted. A civilised society is judged on how it treats its minorities and while progress has been made on LGBT issues, we still have a long way to go.

  • Lisamareedom

    Well, they have got rid of Westlife. So that’s a start?

  • Jillian van Turnhout

    I would add holding a Referendum to strengthen children’s rights in the Irish Constitution – so that we can incorporate the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child into Irish Law. Childhood doesn’t stand still and yet children seem to be constantly put at the back of the queue of Referendums. This year it must be different.

  • shoot the messenger

    perhaps a hiqa inspectorate that can go anywhere, at anytime, where profoundly comprehension challenged, fully supported citizens (no not clients and no not lifespan solutions) of all ages are cared for – residential, educational or day care -

  • observer

    Insert other areas where Ireland’s human rights record is poor and we fail to meet international conventions

    In a nomrative sense our human rights record may be poor, but in a comparative sense we are amongst one of the top 10 to 15% of UN members.

    You may forget that but our human rights record is better than than about 145 other countries.

  • Oireachtas Retort

    You may forget that but our human rights record is better than than about 145 other countries.

    ^

    Indicative of appalling standards across the board rather then any achievement on our part mind..

  • Mauled by the Celtic Tiger – CESR report published

    [...] Occupied Palestinian Territories, Peru, Spain, Syria, United States. All this before Ireland seeks election to the UN Human Rights council next [...]

Leave a Comment